Apparently, we've been way off. He's way better than that.
At least, that's what the horde of scouts that have made their way out to watch the Arizona Fall League have been saying. MLB's Jonathan Mayo pondered his ability to turn water into wine. Minor League analyst John Sickels has unabashedly called Wieters "a mutant cross" between Joe Mauer, the game's best defensive catcher today, and Mike Piazza, the game's most destructive offensive force ever to play behind the plate. Not bad.
After years of bad draft picks, and rushing the ones that were good to the majors too quickly (ahem, Adam Loewen), the Orioles have gotten two stellar picks in a row in Wieters and lefty pitcher Brian Matusz, and have been consistent in their desires to keep the phenoms down until they're absolutely ready.
With his performance in Arizona, it's time to wonder if that day is coming fast for Mr. Wieters.